I don't get it. The general view of Palin's speech last night is that she did a great job. Instapundit has a
poll (unscientific, obviously) with the overwhelmingly dominant view that she "Knocked it out of the park". It was a terrible speech. It just emphasized how desperate the Republicans are.
Let's start with the crowd reaction. They acted like they loved it. She mentions that she has a union husband, and the crowd roars. She mentions that she's proud of her child, and the crowd roars. These are substantive points worthy of crowd approval? No, it's a sign of a crowd desperate to applaud anything coming out of her mouth so that their nominee doesn't look so ridiculous in his choice of running mate.
Comments like "I put it up on eBay" come across like a middle-aged parent of teenagers, which Palin is, trying to show how cool and hip they are. And the crowd roars. I guess they can relate.
What about the content? What content? One praise I've heard is her use of humor, by which they really mean sarcasm. I'm a sarcastic person, so I appreciate the use of sarcasm to make a point. But what point did she make, repeatedly? That she's been an executive, and therefore has the experience that the Obama/Biden ticket lacks. OK, this goes along with the GOP theme that their opponents aren't ready. Mayor Guiliani said essentially the same thing during his speech. But is this really the message the GOP wants to send, that being a senator does not give one experience and help one get prepared to be president, and that only those with executive backgrounds are ready? As part of trying to get
Senator McCain elected? This doesn't seem to be an exactly constructive spin on the experience theme.
Finally, to emphasize McCain's maverick nature, the speech ends with McCain breaking tradition and trotting out on stage with his running mate. Just as Obama did the week before. Surely he wasn't trying to imitate his opponent, was he? They just had the same idea, at the same time. And rather than have a change of scenery for the main attraction by moving the stage to a big stadium, they're just going to
rearrange the stage. McCain is Obama on a budget!
I'm not an Obama person. I'm actually kind of uncomfortable with him. But the Republicans are not exactly giving me much of an alternative. Are they actually trying in this election?
I will commend Gov. Palin for her delivery. Last night had to have been easily the largest crowd she's ever spoken to, and that doesn't include the millions watching on TV. It had to be nerve wracking for her, but she delivered a smooth and confident speech, looking at home in the political big-time. It's not clear, though, how she will fare with a less amenable and enthusiastic crowd, and in the less controlled environment of stump speeches and vice-presidential debates.
Update: Andrew Sullivan
comments, "I have to say that the affect is of someone running for high school president."